Melissa & Doug Chunky Puzzle (single)

A single Melissa & Doug chunky puzzle (vehicles, animals, dinosaurs, or pets) runs about $10 and is the ideal small toddler gift. The fat handles, stand-up pieces, and forgiving fit make it work from 18 months to 3 years. We’d buy this as a baby-shower add-on or birthday-card-with-a-toy gift — punches above its weight.